440.285.8655
Browne & Co
  • Home
  • About
  • Cutting Tools
    • Carbro
    • CFT - George Whalley
    • Dapra
    • Dummel
    • Everede Tool
    • Fullerton Tool
    • Gaylee Saw
    • Lexington Cutter
    • Nine 9
    • Regal
    • Rockhard
    • Rocky Mountain Twist
  • Accessories
    • ACS - Advanced Chem
    • Alpha Tools
    • Boneham
    • Endurance Carbide
    • Haimer
    • MRO Solutions
    • Precision Brand
    • Safeway Sling
    • Tuffy Products
  • News
  • Contact

A Machinist’s Guide to Trochoidal and Peel Milling: Part One

10/9/2019

1 Comment

 
Make it From Metal blog
Written by:  Jonathan Maes
Originally Published on "Make it from Metal"
Jonathan has been working in manufacturing and repair for the past 12 years. His specialty is machining. He manages a machine shop with multiaxis CNC machines for aerospace and medical prototyping and contract manufacturing.

This is the first of a two part series. This part will discuss the fundamentals of Trochoidal and Peel Milling and the next part will discuss what is required for Peel and Trochoidal Milling covering toolholders, cutting tools and cam systems
Fullerton Fury 3500 End Mill Peel Milling
Fullerton Fury 3500 End Mill is ideal for Trochoidal and Peel Milling
All the aspects of high speed machining can be a real challenge to wrap your head around. Filtering through what’s real and what’s just a buzzword can be a chore in and of itself.

So is peel milling a technique worth learning?
Definitely.

Peel milling is an approach that uses high feed rates, low radial depth of cut and high axial depth of cut. It relies heavily on the principle of chip thinning, using a tool path that maximizes tool wear along the entire flute length.

Trochoidal peel milling is a particular type of motion – a circular high speed maneuver that is excellent for carving out deep slots and other narrow features.
Ok, that was pretty packed with information. Let’s break that up and use a few diagrams to explain what’s going on, how to do it properly, and how to know when your application justifies it.

Peel Milling Principles

The basic idea here is to use a small stepover, usually around 10% of the tool’s diameter, but max out the Z depth.

Of course, when using this method in the real world, you’re best off consulting the cutting tool manufacturer for recommended cutting parameters, but these numbers are usually pretty realistic.

For example, if you have a 0.500″ endmill, you’ll cut at a depth of 1.0″ but with a stepover of 0.050″. Compare that to a standard approach of cutting with a depth of 0.250″ and a stepover of 70%, or 0.350″.

Traditional milling vs. Peel Milling
Traditional milling vs. Peel Milling. Compare a 0.500″ endmill performing a Traditional milling approach of cutting with a depth of 0.250″ and a stepover of 70%, or 0.350″ on the left to Peel Milling with a depth of cut of 1.0″ and a stepover of 0.050″on the right.
Now if we look at the area of cutting engagement, we can work out what kind of stock removal we can get.

For the standard milling approach, we’re cutting an area that’s 0.250″ x 0.350″, or an area of 0.0875 square inches.

TRADITIONAL-MILLING-AREA-Large
Traditional milling cut area
PEEL-MILLING-AREA-Large
Peel milling cut area
For the peel milling approach, we’re cutting an area that’s 0.050″ x 1.000″, or 0.050 square inches.
At this point, it’s not too impressive, is it? Peel milling doesn’t have nearly the same engagement as the traditional approach.

But there’s a secret sauce.

Peel milling can take advantage of something called chip thinning.

If you take a look at the size of chip that you get with such a low radial engagement, you’ll realize that it’s actually super thin. What this means is that you can crank up the feed rate to get a normal chip thickness.

TRADITIONAL-MILLING-FEED1-Large
Traditional milling chip thickness
PEEL-MILLING-FEED-Large
Peel milling chip thickness
According to those sketches, you can cut the material with a 70% higher feed rate and have the same chip thickness as the “traditional machining” model.

Now let’s convert those previous examples from 2D area to 3D volume.
To do this, we’ll need to add some material data to come up with realistic feed rates. Let’s say that we’re cutting 4140 HTSR. We’ll use a cutting speed of 400 SFM for standard machining. Let’s see what that stock removal looks like.

For conventional machining, the RPM works out to 3200 RPM. We’ll use a feed rate of 0.003″ per tooth, using a standard 4 flute endmill. This means that we’ll be feeding the cutter at 38.4 inches per minute.
Taking that same cut of 0.250 deep x 0.350 stepover, our 2D cut is 0.0875 square inches. To convert that to cubic inches per minute, we’ll multiply that by our feedrate.

0.1875 square inches x 38.4 inches per minute = 3.36 cubic inches per minute.

Now let’s compare that to peel milling. To maintain the same 0.003″ chip thickness at 0.050″ stepover, the feed can be increased to 0.0051″ per tooth. Another perk of peel milling is that the RPM can also be bumped up.

So let’s increase that RPM to 500 SFPM, using a 0.0051″ chip per tooth. This works out to 4000 RPM, and a feed rate of 81.6 IPM. As mentioned previously, the 0.050″ stepover and 1.000″ depth of cut works out to an area of 0.050 square inches.

0.050 square inches x 81.6 inches per minute = 4.08 cubic inches per minute.

That’s about 15% faster material removal than the traditional approach. But the advantages of peel milling don’t end there.

Maximizing Tool Wear

One of the real disadvantages of the traditional roughing approach is that wear is very concentrated to the bottom of the end mill.

Using that same previous example, what would our endmill look like after an hour of work?

The bottom 0.250″ would be worn out, and the top 0.750″ would be totally fresh. Not really maximizing the use of the tool, is it? Now aside from the cost of the endmill itself, add the down time of the machine operator swapping the tool for a fresh endmill. Overall, it’s just not an efficient method.

Now compare that to the tool that’s used for peel milling. What would that tool look like after an hour?

Instead of all the wear focused on 25% of the tool, the wear would be evenly distributed across the entire flute length.

Also, because of the small radial engagement, the individual flutes are actually in the cut for less time. Let me illustrate.

TRADITIONAL-MILLING-CUT-TIME
For the traditional milling example, the flutes are cutting for 112.89 out of 360 degrees, or about 30 percent of a full rotation. In other words, for every minute of cutting, the individual flutes are working for 18 seconds
PEEL-MILLING-CUT-TIME-Large
For the peel milling example, the flutes are cutting for 36.87 out of 360 degrees, or about 10 percent of a full rotation. This means that for every minute of cutting, the individual flutes are working for only 6 seconds.
To put it simply, the actual working time of the cutter’s flutes is about 1/3 of the time for peel milling compared to traditional milling.

Does this mean that your cutters last 3x as long? Not always, in my experience. But I do tend to improve tool life noticeably, especially in hard to machine materials like titanium, inconel and cobalt chrome.

Check back for the next installment:  What’s Required for Peel and Trochoidal Milling?

In the next article, Jonathan will discuss Trochoidal Peel Milling Toolpaths and what is required for Peel and Trochoidal Milling covering toolholders, cutting tools and cam systems. Check back soon!
1 Comment
Chance Cook link
9/17/2021 13:03:59

I appreciate your response about how peel milling is worth learning. A ton of people might assume that you only need to learn certain forms of milling. But peel milling could be one of those if it can help out.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    We've compiled the latest news and technical information about our principals and our market that we hope you find informative!

    Archives

    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    June 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    April 2013
    February 2013
    September 2012
    February 2012
    October 2011
    July 2011
    April 2011
    January 2011
    November 2010
    October 2010
    August 2010
    April 2010
    February 2010
    July 2009
    January 2009
    July 2007

    Categories

    All
    Abrasives
    Advanced Chemical Solutions
    Aerospace
    AirLoc
    Allen Benjamin
    Alpha Tool
    AlumaMill
    Arno Fast Change
    Arno USA
    Asimeto
    Award
    Back Chamfer
    Beveling Base Starter Kit
    Bishop Lifting Products
    Boneham
    Boring
    Boring Bars
    Brian Martin
    Browne & Co.
    Carbide Cutting Tools
    Carbide Drills
    CAT40
    CAT50
    Catalog Download
    Chamfer
    Chip Thinning
    Circular Saws
    Clamping
    Coating
    Coolant
    Coronovirus
    Countersinks
    Custom Tooling
    Cutting Tools
    Dapra
    Dapra Vapor
    Deburring
    Deep Hole Drilling
    Drill Bushing
    Drilling
    Drill Points
    Drills
    Dummel
    Dümmel
    End Mill
    Endurance Carbide
    ER Colllet
    ERGO
    Everede
    Everede Tool
    Fantom
    Feeler Gage
    Flap Wheels
    Forged Wheels
    Fullerton Tool
    Fury
    Gage Reconditioning
    Gaylee Saws
    Gemtex
    George Whalley
    Grooving
    GWS Tool Group
    Haimer USA
    Harmon-i-Cut
    HB Rouse
    HSK
    H Tolerance
    Hydromat
    IBC
    IMTS
    Industrial Supply Assoc
    InovaTool
    Inserts - Boring
    Inserts Grooving
    Inserts - Grooving
    Inserts Milling
    Inserts Parting
    Inserts - Parting
    Inserts- Turning
    Intimidator
    ISA Industrial Supply Assoc
    ISO-9001
    Jergens
    Lexington Cutter
    Live Center
    Lubricants
    Machining Cloud
    Made In USA
    Manufacturing
    Martindale Saws
    Mastercam
    Material: Aluminum
    Material: Bronze
    Material: Cast Iron
    Material: Chromium
    Material: Copper
    Material High Temp
    Material: Inconel
    Material: Steel
    Material: Titanium
    Measuring Tools
    Memorial Day
    Metals
    Metalworking
    Metalworking Fluid
    Metrology
    Mill Turn
    Minimill
    MRO
    Multifunctional Tool
    Nanotech 7000
    NASA
    NATC
    NC Helix Drill
    Nine9
    North American Tool
    Ohio
    Peel Milling
    PMTS
    Polisher
    Precision Brand
    Promotions
    Punches
    QR Code
    Reamers
    Regal
    Rep Of The Year
    RMT Rocky Mountain Twist
    Roll Form Taps
    Rouse Arno
    Rouse - Arno
    Safeway Sling
    Sales
    Sales Tools
    Saw
    Saw Arbors
    Screw Threads
    Shim Stock
    Shrink FIt
    Sling Inspection
    Sling Safety
    Slip Plate
    Sowa
    Spade Drills
    Special Cutting Tools
    Special Tools
    S&R Products
    Stonecutter
    Swiss Machining
    Tap: Carbide
    Tap: Carbide Insert
    Tap Chamfer
    Tap Definitions
    Tap: Extension
    Tap: Metric
    Tapping
    Tap: Pulley
    Taps
    Tap: STI
    Tap: Thread Forming
    Technical Support
    Thread Gaging
    Threading
    ThreadMills
    Thread Tap App
    TIMill
    Tire Mold
    Tool Balancing
    Tool Black
    Toolholders
    Tool Presetter
    Tool Selection
    Tool Wrap
    Trochoidal Milling
    Troubleshooting
    Tuffy Products
    Turning Tools
    Valspar
    Vibration Pads
    Vises
    Weldon Flat
    Workholding

    RSS Feed

Browne & Co., Inc.
9605 Tanager Drive
Chardon, Ohio 44024
Phone 440.285.8655
Fax 440.285.8653
dmb@brownesales.com
© 2023 Browne & Co., Inc. All Rights Reserved
web design by Rapid Production Marketing